10.05.21

Sourcing Feedback from Unsuccessful Interviews

 

Asking why you were unsuccessful after an interview or why you missed out on a job opportunity can be an uncomfortable or daunting experience for some.

Unfortunately, some organisations won’t provide you with any feedback by not returning your calls or emails (which probably says more about them..) or if they do then you may simply receive the standard line of “another candidate had more experience” or “displayed a greater fit”.

On the other hand, if you are able to source some specific feedback then this could end up being a very handy benefit for future interviews / applications.

Some benefits of seeking feedback include:

  • Future opportunities within the organization – seeking feedback in a professional manner shows that you are serious about continuous improvement and that you are genuinely interested in the organization. You may have only just missed out on being the preferred candidate so they may come back to you if other opportunities arise or if the original candidate does not work out in their probationary period!

 

  • Improve performance – seeking feedback obviously allows you to improve your performance in future interviews if you are able to get some specific feedback, eg becoming more detailed and less general in answers to behavioural questions.

 

  • Reinforcement of strengths- not all feedback is negative or constructive – you may receive some positive feedback about certain aspects as well!

 

  • Keeping an eye on the competition / market – feedback may highlight how other candidates may have differentiated themselves from you, eg some may have had a particular qualification, licence or clearance which in the end was the deciding factor. This could then lead to you exploring similar options to make this less of an issue moving forwards.

 

Generally, the best approach to source feedback is by email as this allows the respondent to possibly give better quality feedback when they have time. 

Some people also feel a bit uncomfortable in giving feedback in person or on the phone so this option provides them with a bit more leeway.

Another option could also be to connect with the potential feedback provider on LinkedIn and then message them – as well as hopefully getting some feedback you are also able to expand your network which is also beneficial.

When sending a feedback request, then ensure the following:

  • Thank them for their time and for considering you
  • Express disappointment in the decision but do it graciously and professionally!
  • Explain why you are emailing and seeking feedback.
  • Keep the email brief and send within 24 hours of rejection (if possible).

An example is as follows:

Dear Ms Smith.

Thank you for the opportunity to be considered for the …… role with “Company X”.

Whilst I am obviously disappointed that I was unsuccessful on this occasion, I also respect your decision and appreciated the opportunity to learn more about “Company X”

I would like to reinforce my strong interest in working for “company X” so please do not hesitate to contact me should any future roles arise that suit my capabilities.

Also, if you have the time, I would greatly appreciate any feedback regarding my interview or application that may assist in the future. 

Once again, thanks again for your time and the opportunity to interview for ….role with “Company X”.

Yours Sincerely.

Name

Mob Number

 

Good luck with this process – learning of the fact that you were unsuccessful with an application is never easy however try and turn a negative into a professional development experience for the future!

 

Paul Bell

Principal Consultant, Hender Careers

Read More

How to Answer “Why Should We Hire You?” in an Interview

by Joel Schwartzberg, Nov 8, 2024 Summary.   How do you tell a potential employer that you’re right for the job they are interviewing you for? If you make it all about yours...
Read More

7 Questions to Ask When Weighing a Job Offer

Source: https://hbr.org/Accept a job offer - or not? Do your due diligence.This is a handy article to remind candidates and job seekers of elements to consider before accepting a job offer. It is impo...
Read More

Great Interview Tips - Tried and True for Situational Interview Questions

Gone are the days when interviewers merely probed job candidates about their strengths and weaknesses. Today, recruiters and hiring managers are keen on assessing how candidates think and solve proble...
Read More

Managing Yourself - 6 Questions to Ask at the Midpoint of Your Career

by Rebecca KnightSummary.   It’s common to wrestle with feelings of unmet expectations, missed opportunities, and paths not taken when you reach the midpoint of your career. But experts sa...
Read More

Why business leaders can’t cope with criticism

Business leaders who use reputation specialists and chiefs of staff become unable to hear dissenting voices or handle public criticism, speechwriter and author Lucinda Holdforth says.Ms Holdforth – ...
Read More

3-Step Structure for Effective Communication

A Great and Simple Framework for structured and effective communication - verbal or written. It can transcend many a scenario, including interview responses, providing feedback to someone, or pitching...
Read More

LinkedIn Tips

Creating a strong LinkedIn profile is crucial for building a professional online presence. Here are some tips to help you craft an effective LinkedIn profile:Professional Photo:Use a high-quality, pro...
Read More

Employment Market Trends. Are you in the Market for a new job or looking to recruit? If so – read on!

Employment Market Trends. Are you in the Market for a new job or looking to recruit? If so – read on!#employment #markettrends #jobads Some key points / facts to consider as you reflect on...
Read More

Responding to Criteria - What do STAR and SAO have in common?

Michelle Bentley, General Manager Hender Careers They are a great framework for Addressing Criteria in Job Applications. Of the thousands of people, I have assisted in application developmen...